13 May 2018 at Anthony Spaulding Sports Complex, Kingston (Jamaica)
Club Atlético Pantoja (Dominican Republic) vs. Arnett Gardens FC (Jamaica) (0-0 shootout: 6-5)
Referee: Joel Aguilar (El Salvador)
Assistant Referee: Juan Zumba (El Salvador)
Assistant Referee: Corey Rockwell (USA)
4th official: Jair Marrufo (USA)